Fatty's Seafood Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Fatty's Seafood, where Cajun and Creole flavors come alive in every dish. Located in Picayune, Mississippi, this casual dining spot is perfect for families, date nights, or group gatherings. The restaurant boasts a menu rich in seafood delights, featuring standout items like the Crab Cake Sandwich and the savory Catfish Po' Boy. Vegetarians aren't left out, with multiple options catering to diverse tastes.
Start your meal with Bacon Wrapped Shrimp, perfectly complemented by sweet pepper jelly, or indulge in Crab Claws, available fried or sautéed. For mains, don't miss the Fatty Melt—a glorious mix of meats and cheeses soaked in gravy.
- Relax in the outdoor seating area or enjoy a special Happy Hour drink.
- Fatty's also emphasizes sustainability with plastic-free packaging and reusable tableware.
Experience the essence of Louisiana in every bite at Fatty's Seafood!
Sandwiches
Bogue Chitto Chicken
Fatty's favorite. Blackened chicken breast, cheddar cheese, bacon & bbq sauce
Canal Club
American & swiss cheese, bacon, ham & turkey dressed with lettuce, tomato & mayo. Served on texas toast
The Rigger
Hand pattied burger served on brioche bun. Add cheese, bacon & jalapeños for additional price.
Crab Cake Sandwich
Our panko fried crab cake dressed with lettuce and creole remoulade. Served on brioche bun
The Fatty Melt
Fatty's favorite. Ham, roast beef & turkey sautéed in gravy with onions, mushrooms & jalapeños, smothered with swiss & american cheese. Debris gravy on the side, by request.
Catfish Po boy
Catfish po' boy available in half or whole servings. Choice of sides: variety of fries, potato & corn combos, assorted dressing side salads, loaded potato souflee, veggies, or our famous gouda grits!
Homemade Roast Beef
Slow cooked home made roast beef po-boy!
Pistol Pete
Blackened shrimp, sautéed onions & peppers, pepper jack cheese, dressed with lettuce & creole remoulade
Oyster Po Boy
Oyster po' boy, choice of half or whole. Select sides: fries variations, salads with multiple dressings,potato options, veggies, baked macaroni, onion rings, bayou boudin rice, gouda grits, and more
Po'boys
Starters
Crab Claws
Your choice fried or sauteed
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
A creamy new orleans specialty! served with italian breaded fried bowtie pasta
Crab Cakes
Panko fried and loaded with jumbo lump crabmeat served with remoulade sauce.
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Fatty's favorite. Shrimp stuffed with cream cheese & jalapeños wrapped in bacon. Served with our signature pepper jelly for dipping.
Onion Rings
Crispy, golden-fried onion rings served with a side of creamy dipping sauce.
Bayou Boudin Balls
Fatty's favorite. Served with remoulade
Peyton's Pickles
Served with ranch
Hush Puppy Basket
Baker's dozen of our sweet corn hushpuppies!!!
The Original Seafood Nachos
Fatty's favorite. Hand-cut flour tortilla chips topped with our scratch-made jalapeño queso, blackened shrimp, crabmeat & other delicious spices! a guest favorite!
Fatty Fries
A generous portion of fries smothered with pepper jack cheese, jalapeos, bacon & blackened shrimp.
BBQ Shrimp
A new orleans classic, served with plenty of bread for dipping!
Shareables
Soup
Corn & Crab Bisque
Fatty's favorite.
Seafood Okra Gumbo
Served with shrimp, crabmeat & okra.
Garden Salad
Tomato, cucumber, cheddar & housemade croutons. Add chicken or shrimp (grilled, blackened or fried at a cost.
Caesar Salad
Romaine, parmesan & housemade croutons. Add chicken or shrimp (grilled, blackened or fried) at a cost.
The Sonny
Golden fried shrimp & crawfish, pepper jack cheese, tomato, cucumber, boiled egg & housemade croutons, served with ranch dressing
Tchoup Chicken Salad
Tuscan garlic grilled chicken and chopped greens, bacon, tomato, cucumber, avocado, pepper jack cheese & housemade croutons tossed in your choice of dressing
Salads
Boiled Seafood
Boiled Shrimp 1 LB
1lb boiled shrimp tails served with corn & potatoes
Royal Reds 1 LB
1 LB of Royal Reds (Tails) served with corn, potatoes, and melted butter for dipping!
Snow Crab Plate
Two snow crab clusters served with corn & potatoes!
Shrimp Plate
Fried shrimp with french fries, hush buppies and toast!
Catfish Plate
Crispy fried catfish fillets served with seasoned fries, hush puppies, and a lemon wedge.
Shrimp Sampler
Stuffed shrimp, tail-on shrimp & popcorn shrimp
Crab Cake Plate
A duo of crab cakes, typically featuring lump crab meat, lightly breaded and fried, accompanied by a tangy rémoulade sauce.
Crabmeat Stuffed Shrimp
Four tail-on, butterflied jumbo shrimp, stuffed full of our crabmeat stuffing & lightly fried to golden brown
Cap'n Fatty
Catfish, shrimp, crab cake, stuffed shrimp, popcorn shrimp, oysters, hushpuppies and toast - add a soft shell crab for additional cost.
Jr. Cap'n Fatty
Catfish, shrimp, crab cake, stuffed shrimp, popcorn shrimp, hushpuppies and toast!!! Add a soft shell crab for additional cost.
Half & Half Platter
Half fried shrimp and half fried catfish, served with fries, toast and hush puppies
Oyster Plate
Golden fried oysters with fries, hushpuppies and toast!
Pontchartrain Pete
Featuring all of the BEST from Lake Pontchartrain: loaded with crab fingers, soft shell crab, popcorn shrimp, jumbo shrimp, and oysters!!!
Fried Seafood Plates
Pastas
Crabmeat Stuffed Bell Peppers
Two tender bell peppers, stuffed with our family's crabmeat stuffing recipe, served with angel hair pasta tossed in our bienville sauce!
Cajun Alfredeaux
Fatty's favorite. Our twist on an italian classic- creamy sauce tossed with sautéed crawfish, peppers, and other cajun spices over fettuccine & topped with fried crawfish tails sub fried shrimp for additional cost.
Alfredo Erin
Your choice of grilled or blackened chicken in our creamy alfredo sauce. Sub shrimp for additional cost.
Four Seasons
Grilled shrimp & crawfish are tossed in our creole cream sauce over fettuccini & topped with lump crabmeat & fried gulf oysters
Crab Trap
Our crab stuffing, balled up & trapped inside of two fried catfish strips, tossed with crawfish étouffée, served over angel hair pasta
Seafood Napoleon
Layered italian breaded eggplant medallions and panko fried crabcake lightly fried and topped with our shrimp & crabmeat cream sauce served over angel hair pasta!
The Fat Cat
Fatty's favorite. Crawfish étouffée served over rice & topped with fried catfish. Substitute fried shrimp for additional cost.
Crawfish Two Step
New. We've amped up our traditional crawfish étouffée dish by adding fried crawfish tails on top-once you try it, you'll never go back!
Gris Gris Shrimp & Grits
This southern staple is kicked up with our jalapeño cheese sauce, sauteed onions, peppers & bacon
The Cuco
Three shrimp tacos (blackened or fried) dressed with cabbageslaw, pico and sriracha mayo, served with chips & queso
Redfish Acadiana
Blackened redfish topped with crawfish etouffee, served with bayou boudin rice & sauteed vegetables!
Blackened Chicken Plate
two 6 oz chicken breast, served with baked macaroni, and our house veggies!
Handcut Prime Certified Ribeye 14oz
Our handcut 14oz prime certified ribeye served with loaded potato souflee, and our house veggies!
Fatty's Signature Entrees
On The Side
Sweet Potato Fries
Crispy sweet potato fries seasoned with a hint of salt.
Waffle Fries
Crispy waffle-cut potato fries, golden and seasoned.
Loaded Potato Soufflé
Creamy potato soufflé topped with melted cheddar cheese and crispy bacon bits.
Boiled Potatoes & Corn
Tender boiled red potatoes paired with sweet corn on the cob.
Sauteéd Veggies
A medley of vegetables, typically carrots, broccoli, cauliflower, zucchini, and squash, sautéed with olive oil and garlic.
Baked Macaroni
Rich and creamy macaroni baked to golden perfection with a blend of cheeses.
Gouda Grits
Smoked Gouda Grits!
Bayou Boudin Rice
Our twist on a dirty rice made with our in house boudin!!!
Bread Pudding
Served with whiskey sauce!
Creole Cheesecake
Smooth, creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust, topped with a dollop of whipped cream and drizzled with a vibrant red syrup.